Earlier tonight I was watching Glee with my eight year old sister. At some point, a scene came on where Kurt (the gay guy) was interacting with Finn (the sensitive jock). After seeing Kurt make a few comments to Finn, she randomly commented, "Eww, did you know he's gay (referring to Kurt)? He moves like a girl." I simply gave her an affirmative response, which she responded to by asking, "Are you gay?" Again, I gave her a simple answer, "Yes." Her response should have been obvious to me, but for some reason I was taken aback when she responded with, "Ew." The most salient thoughts I had in mind at that point was, "Oh God, is she going to tell my parents that I told her I was gay? Where is this going to lead? Did she seriously respond in revulsion to me being gay?"
Sure, children around the age of my sister are repulsed by the very idea of attraction between two people, but this was different. My sister's reaction was not a response to the idea of two people being attracted to one another and contracting cooties, but to the particular concept of two men having mutual interest in each other. How can a child react with such disapproval and/or disgust? As the concepts of dichotomous systems of sex and gender are social constructs, I can confidently say that her response was not an inherent reaction, but something socially learned. Who could she have learned such a response from?
One person came to mind as to who my little could have learned modeled her response from: our father. Throughout my childhood, and even to this day, my father refers to people (whether they be acquaintances or strangers) that seem effeminate or who are confirmed homosexuals as "bakla." In my native language, "bakla" means gay or homosexual, but it holds a more negative connotation in comparison to the English word "gay" or "homosexual." Frankly, there is no word in our native language that objectively means to be individuals (specifically men) that are attracted to the same sex/gender. Bakla doesn't just hold this definition, but is also followed by the implication of weakness, femininity, and perhaps even sexual deviance.
My parents have never directly expressed to my little sister their disapproval of homosexuality, but nonetheless, I know that my sister has picked up on their attitudes towards homosexuals. Children are easily influenced by the social microsystem they inhabit; as they perceive how those closest to them react to certain individuals and situations, they interpret those reactionary behaviors as relative social norms or even as the "correct" response.
It's interesting and disappointing at the same time as my family knows (whether we speak of it or not) that I am gay. Even with this in mind, my parents' homophobic attitude has not changed even when confronted by their son's homosexual identity. I am gay, but to them I am not a part of such a group identity, but an exception. They accept me as their son, but they do not accept a facet of my identity that has a salient presence in my life. Therefore, conceptually, for them, gay people are still repulsive and I am just an exception to such a judgment.
From time to time I hear would my father exclaim how a person on the television is "bakla," expressing a negative opinion of the person through the word's negative implications rather than the latter's alleged sexuality. It hurts to hear him make these statements even though he's talking about me. It hurts because in a sense he is indirectly expressing an opinion of me. If a gay person that is not me is as repulsive as he claims or acts towards them, then without the condition of being his son, does he not hold the same opinion of me? For I am also gay?
I truly do believe that it is too late to change and/or improve my father's opinion of homosexuality. He is a bigot, a sexist, and a racist, traits he is not ashamed to display. I just hope that it is not too late for my sister; I am her older brother and it would be heartbreaking if my little sister came to hold the same opinions as my father, considering that I basically raised her from when she was an infant.
Jeez, if my hypothetical little sister said "ew," I would've either immediately went to my room to cry a little or asked why it was disgusting to her (and then go to my room and cry a little).
ReplyDeleteThe reaction being socially learned? I believe so. Perhaps some internal repulsion mixed in as well. But she's young and impressionable, so it can't be helped.
I guess an important question to ask is if she loves you. If she does and you feel it's your responsibility, I believe you still have a chance at changing her mind. Even if she doesn't love you, start building rapport if you wish. Ultimately that might mean more conflicts with your father.
I just have a little concern with how often you see her/talk to her(in reference to your Family: What it Means to Me as a Gay Teen post). Don't pass on the sadness you felt when your older sisters stopped walking you to school!
Well, that's a part of the question though: where would the internal repulsion really be inherent? I have come across children that think no different of heterosexual and homosexual relationships, they simply shrug and walk away.
ReplyDeleteI don't really think her familial love for me is questionable. She is my sister and she is eight years old, so the things that have crossed my mind and all its complexities probably hasn't crossed her own. What concerns me is as to whether the things I observe now symptomatic of what could develop as concrete homophobia in the future.
Frankly, my absence from my parents' home is an inevitable, if not necessary, choice of mine. To find a sense of individuality and to prevent myself from sowing anymore resentment for my parents/family, I had/have to separate myself and actually live of my own determination.
At that age I wouldn't be too concerned about your sister's views. Like you said kids are very easily influenced by social norms and ideas they get from others but with time they will develop their own views and opinions.
ReplyDeleteWhat's important right now is to foster a good relationship with your sister and being a good brother to her. Even if she does end up harbouring less than accepting views of gays in the future, your relationship with each other is the most important part to preserve.
I'm not too concerned about my relationship with my sister. Frankly, considering our situation and our family structure, it's the best it can be. I guess the possibility of her harboring distaste for homosexuals, when her own brother identifies as one is disheartening.
ReplyDeleteMeanwhile, what also concerns me is the fact that my parents' own personal views are alienating me; it's something I cannot avoid feeling.
Well KC I think the myth about homosexuality that bugs me the most is that being gay means a guy is 'girly' and a girl is 'masculine'. And there is certainly nothing wrong with that, but implying that ALL gay guys are effeminate is a lie. I remember at a place I worked there was a young man in his twenties who I assumed was gay cos he had all the 'stereotypical' qualities. Then a girl came around taking up a collection for a baby shower present for his FIFTH child! Point is that heterosexuals have their share of effeminate type guys but they never mention that. You can check a lot of gay websites and see lots of very masculine and well-hung gay guys. Gay guys are just as proud of their masculinity as any hetero guy. But your little sister has been brain-washed into thinking all gay guys are not masculine and therefore has a negative attitude, with lots of help from your father. Not too long ago I was watching CNN and they were talking about a mother concerned that her 5yr old son liked dresses. They immediately talked about the possibility of her son being 'gay', like all gays want to wear dresses! (the kid may be transsexually inclined, not gay) The steam was coming out of my very masculine gay ears! Thus the term 'gay' is being equated with being feminine and is the ultimate insult to any jock. (in spite of all the gay guys into sports) I assure you I would have a hard time convincing someone I am gay.
ReplyDelete-Yeah, your father is probably beyond hope; maybe if you put him in contact with PFLAG he might be enlightened. And the hurt you feel because of what your little sister and father say is a bitterness that all homosexuals my age still feel. I hope you can have a talk with your little sister about prejudice and racism someday, and how important it is to have a live-and-let-live attitude in life. bfn - Wayne
Family can be such a burden sometimes. But we love 'em...
ReplyDeleteI think your sister will be just fine because even now, most youths don't find anything distasteful about homosexuals. Imagine this in 5-10 years time when she meets one in higher schooling. Even for Filipinos...
ReplyDeleteWhat I think is more disconcerting is you're parents reactions. They know you're gay? And yet they still act that way? That seems to be the most troubling aspect of your familial relationship because, in my own mind, it's either "No" or "okay" to one's sexuality, not this gray area in between where they still abhor it everywhere else, just not in their son...
What happens when you have a boyfriend? Are you going to be coupled together as "gross" or just him?
Your relationship with your father, I think and this is presumptous so feel free to stop reading at a this point because I hate it too when people give advice I didn't ask for --- needs to be addressed. And if that is addressed with positive outcomes then the way you're sister grows in that household will be all the better.
Thank you all for the responses you've given me. I guess the situation with my little sister really isn't the problem. I guess, in a sense, the attitude within my family towards homosexuals is what's most concerning, with the former just a tag-along concern.
ReplyDeleteHonestly, I don't really know if anything good could come from addressing my concerns with my father; he's a proud, egotistical man that would rather shun something than actually acknowledge it.